Hm treasury, green book appraisal and evaluation in. Annex a godalming flood alleviation scheme outline business case. The five case model is the uk public sector best practice approach to developing business cases. New fcerm project appraisal guidance for wales kevin keating principal engineer mott macdonald kevin. Apr 18, 20 all public spending proposals should be accompanied by a properly developed and structured business case using the treasury five case model and the supplementary green book guidance on. Each business case builds upon that previously prepared. Theory and practice in uk government projects blog in uk government projects, hm treasury green book and five case model provide a structured approach to making and appraising investment proposals. Information about northern ireland guide to expenditure appraisal and evaluation nigeae. This obc does not identify a preferred option but instead describes four example schemes, to help inform discussion around the impacts of different design choices. Commercial case, the financial case and the management case. Business case development process department of finance. The hm treasury green book is the main document setting out government guidance on the appraisal of public investments. A good business case can provide a clear strategy for the progress of your innovation. It should contain the information needed to help the institution make decisions regarding the adoption of the project.
Case study outline business case university of leeds. Recommendations are made by selep ite to selep accountability board for the award of funding. Assessing business cases a short plain english guide 5. Strategic outline cases socs, outline business cases obcs and finally full business cases fbcs in support of individual schemes. It is the project board executive who is responsible for drafting the outline business case, and the following information will need to be included. The primary expectations for key stage documents are summarised in table 3 in the main guidance. Case studies can range from academic research studies to corporate promotional tools trying to sell an ideatheir scope is quite vast. To help with efficient planning and approval of spending proposals for agile digital and it projects, the following clarification of business case guidance has been produced in collaboration. Outline business case obc section for each case of the 5cm 5. Government of bermuda appraisal of bermuda airport. Planning the proposal and preparing the outline business case. Dof business case template for contract extensions. Strategic outline case soc, in support of an investment project, procurement or scheme which has.
Planning the proposal and preparing the outline business case obc 7. Green book guide approval of the obc is sought in order to affirm that the assumptions made, and the options appraised, lead to the best available option being identified. An early assessment and sifting tool for shortlisting options at an early stage of the project or programme development. The university of atlantis is on the outskirts of the city. Find case studies by market research topic discover case studies covering one of over 303 market research specialties. The guidance consolidates other reference sources and is consistent with hm treasurys green book guidance on appraisal of policies, programmes and. An outline business case obc sets out the preliminary thoughts regarding a proposed project. Planning the scheme and preparing the outline business case obc 43. All public spending proposals should be accompanied by a properly developed and structured business case using the treasury five case model.
The obc2 reports key changes since obc1 and provides a basis for dof approval to initiate the formal procurement stage. Dft transport business case guidance the transport. The better business cases training is made up of two parts, the foundation and practitioner levels. Capital regime, investment and property business case.
The decision making process, of which this strategic outline business case forms part, usually takes place in three phases. The social security programme business case pbc provides a view on the whole life costs and benefits of the scottish governments social security programme, over a 30 year timeframe to 2050. Soc, the outline business case obc and the full or final. This business case template provides an outline structure and notes to describe the content required for each section in a business case document. We are developing our business case iteratively, with this outline business case the second of three iterations. Wfga, weltag combines the principles of the hm treasury green book and the five case model for better business cases, with webtag best practice for.
Business case analysis forecasts investment or action outcomes as cash flows, risks, and important nonfinancial impacts. It provides a systematic and objective approach to all stages of the business case process from strategic outline plan sop to. The next step towards delivery of eip is a green book outline business case obc. Assessing business cases a short plain english guide 3 at this stage, you might expect. How to build a business case kpmg has worked with over 100 public sector bodies to produce a practical guide to preparing robust business cases to support both routine and strategic investment decisions. For the outline business case and full business case, provide evidence of providers high. The amount of work and detail put in to this obc and any subsequent full business case should be proportionate to the scale of the project or programme and the expenditure involved.
Hm treasury has updated the green book its guidance on how to. Guidance on the development of business cases march 2016. Outline business case, outline business case and full business case 4. This aspect of the business case, in accordance with hm treasurys green book, documents the wide range of options that have been considered within the broad scope identified in response to the organizations existing and future business needs. Outline business case stage two full business case stage three implementation. The purpose of the document is to approve the business case for the preferred option for the scheme, and move to the next stage in the process i. Introduction to the northern ireland guide to expenditure appraisal and evaluation nigeae what is economic appraisal and when is it required. This hfma toolkit is designed to help organisations produce good quality business cases that take account of all relevant financial and nonfinancial considerations. This section of the business case assesses the economic costs and. It is important to note that in transport, stage 0, the strategic outline plan, is covered by existing documents such as scotlands economic strategy 4, the national.
The department for transports business case guidance sets out how write a full business case for a transport investment. The economic case is the essential core of the business case and should be prepared according to treasurys green book guidance2. These are the strategic outline case soc, the outline business case obc and the full or final business case fbc. Each phase includes the preparation of a business case followed by an investment decision point. Qmu requires a report in the form of the government guidance on green book outline business case development as applied to the universitys vision and outline strategy for the edinburgh innovation park. When the green book update is published, this guidance will be amended as appropriate. We are using the business case to examine the costs and benefits of options to deliver marketwide settlement reform, following the five case model2 methodology for major project business cases. Business case development process and how the five case model applies. The general purpose of obc and the criteria for judging their quality are well established and are set out in the hm treasury s green book appraisal and. Procuring the proposal and preparing the full business case.
Estimates of the financing needs of promising project models through an assessment of their costs and benefits. In the interests of brevity, much of the detailed justification that would be expected of a reallife submission has been omitted. A checklist for assessing business cases is available here. The report sets out the development of a long list. The obc follows on from the strategic outline case soc, completed in early 2018. The soc is the first stage in the business case development process.
The template south east local enterprise partnership. The strategic outline case the purpose of the strategic outline case soc is to provide the necessary information in a format that will enable the authority and any public sector partners to. Are there clear smart objectives in terms of outcomes and are. From advertising to worldwide capabilities, we cover it all. Treasury green book value for money, objective led appraisal, 5cm, proportionate.
Strategy networks spoke to joseph lowe, who is the head of the economics branch at the public spending group at hm treasury, about the five case model that hm treasury employ when making important. The plan is set out using the five cases business case model, outlining the rationale and justification for securing funding from central government to deliver the measures proposed. A case study is a subcategory of research design which investigates problems and offers solutions. For our project business case example were going to imagine a growing company that is struggling under the weight of calls to its sales lines. At this early point the outline business case will only contain a highlevel view, however this is sufficient to authorise the initiation stage, where the detailed business case will be created.
Business case results deliver proof, build confidence, reduce. Joseph lowe from hm treasury on the five case model youtube. Outline business case definition of outline business case. The hmt green book includes guidance on how to discount benefits and costs to obtain the value for money of an investment and how to account for risk and uncertainty in appraisal. Stage 2 outline business case obc the detailed planning phase. Does the case include all the elements of the 5 case model, i. Hm treasury, green book appraisal and evaluation in central. In accordance with the treasury green book, the soc must outline a minimum of.
The key focus of this document is to evidence the case for change and to provide an analysis of the options through which the energy co. The green book is guidance issued by hm treasury on how to appraise policies, programmes and projects. Business cases are developed in line with the treasurys green book five case model. The treasury green book, the capital investment manual and the scottish. Outline business case 1 the obc1 includes a full economic appraisal and provides a basis for approval of the project need, objectives and preferred option. They are examined against hm treasurys green book guidance on. Developing compelling business cases a product and a process webinar news. Outline business case selep bid july 2016 completed business case full business case this bid oct 2017 to feb 2018 design detailed design nov 2017 to sep 2018 a copy of the outline business case for the overall scheme can be found at appendix g. This document is the outline business case obc for london borough of barnets lbb proposed development of the grahame park community hub. The fbc then tests assumptions and affirms this option or otherwise.
The essentials by harvard business school press, case in point. The tables in this paper based on the hm treasurys green book supplementary guidance 3 further lay out how each component of the five case model aligns with the business case development process, and what should be included in each part. Mar 27, 2014 the five case model is the uk public sector best practice approach to developing business cases. The aim of the business case template family is to support your thinking, writing and. The treasury green book, the capital investment manual and the. Full business case fbc develop the preferred option. In the executive summary of your business case, you need to outline the critical success factors which underpin your project for example, give the readers different ways of judging how the project will be deemed successful should it reach the goals you have identified as success factors. Outline plan, is covered by existing documents such as scotlands economic. Outline business case assessed through ite gate process. It should state envisaged outcomes, benefits and potential risks associated with the proposal. Phase 1 strategic outline business case phase 2 outline business case phase 3 full business case each business case builds on the last, but the phased approach enables appropriate investment decisions to be made. The case for change the strategic case value for money the economic case commercially viable the. The plan has been developed in line with the guidance provided by governments joint air quality unit jaqu and her majestys hm treasury green book. Read the refreshed guidance for the treasurys approvals process for programmes and projects.
Better business cases the 5 case model an introduction. All public spending proposals should be accompanied by a properly developed and structured business case using the treasury five case model and the supplementary green book guidance on. This outline business case obc enhances the information supplied in the strategic outline case soc, which was recommended for approved in september 2016. The business case uses this evidence and a compelling rationale to prove onr action choice is the better business decision.
The five case model is the approach for developing business cases recommended by hm treasury, the welsh government and the uk office of government commerce. These are the strategic outline case soc, outline business case obc and full business case fbc. The business case has been prepared on behalf of the garden bridge trust by tfl with input from the department for transport, department of culture, media and sport, and hm treasury, on behalf of the mayor of. Apr 16, 2019 outline business case obc evaluate list of options. Green book guidance on public sector business cases using the. Assessing business cases a short plain english guide. Green book guidance on public sector business cases using. These must be prepared in accordance with the hm treasury green book. Business case development including green book postponed until further notice.
The fbc then tests assumptions and affirms this option or otherwise disproves it and sends the project for reconsideration. May 03, 2018 an introduction to the 5 case model as an assessment for capital expenditure as used by all uk government departments and an increasing number of private and third sector organisations contact. Northern ireland guide to expenditure appraisal and. It has been widely used across central government departments and public sector organisations over the last 10 years. The tables in this paper based on the hm treasurys green book supplementary. Please send completed outline business case templates to tom. This outline business case obc is for scotlands deposit return scheme drs. Treasurys green book guidance on appraisal of policies, programmes and. The uks treasury green book subtitled central government. The pbc uses the good practice set out in hm treasurys green book. Annex a godalming flood alleviation scheme outline. A2p stages of the business case process nhs england. The purpose of this guidance is to ensure that policies, programs and projects adopted are the best ways to achieve policy objectives and make the best use of public resources.
502 751 1383 440 1083 387 1040 97 1583 199 1190 1330 562 1145 1309 266 22 1033 1269 158 513 265 50 933 133 845 1360 929 758 952 249 1169 972 429 517 572 601 461 463